Herr Starr had Jesse in his grip. He was in Masada, guns pointed at him, vulnerable. Then why didn't Starr put him down?

Watch a Sneak Peek of Episode 4 Now

In a private discussion with God, Starr airs his frustrations about not having taken Jesse when he had the chance. But God all-knowing being that he is -- reminds Starr of exactly why he didn't make his move then. Find out why in this sneak peek of tonight's all-new episode.

Catch up on the latest full episode available now on amc.com and the AMC app for mobile and devices.

Preacher airs Sundays 10/9c. To get full episodes, behind-the-scenes video and more, sign up for the weekly Insiders Club.