Avery has a plan to hold Captain hostage, and to say that plan goes terribly awry is a bit of an understatement.

Watch the Talked About Scene from Episode 9

Not only does the plan fail, but Captain ends up in a situation that makes even Dud question what he's seeing in front of him. See how Dud and Ernie react to the horrific scene from the latest episode.

Watch the full episode now on amc.com and the AMC app for mobile and devices.

The Season 1 Finale of Lodge 49 airs Monday at 10/9c on AMC. Click here to add a reminder to your calendar.

For the latest sneak peeks, full episodes and more, sign up for the Lodge 49 Insiders Club.